Please look at the two images below and comment on which you prefer and your reasons, as well as what you think of the quality of detail, creativeness and mood.
Shot using a Canon EOS 5D MII, f/6.3, 1/15, Evaluative Metering, In Portrait mode, focal length 85mm on a Canon EF 28-135 IS USM, ISO 640, No flash fired but lighting from sides and overhead used.
What are your thoughts? (Good and Bad welcomed)